Wednesday, January 12, 2011

When Harry Met Molly


Dashing Lord Harry Traemore is perfectly content to live out his days in the pursuit of pleasure. But when he’s named by the Prince Regent as one of society’s “Impossible Bachelors,” Harry is drafted into a ribald romantic wager. The rules of engagement are scandalously simple: The bachelor whose mistress wins the title of “Most Delectable Companion” gets to remain unmarried. Harry is utterly unconcerned about his status...until his latest lightskirt abandons him.


Enter Lady Molly Fairbanks. Harry’s childhood friend— actually, “foe” is more like it—is the most unlikely companion of all. She’s attractive but hot-headed, and in no mood for games. Besides, what could the self-indulgent Harry possibly know about what makes a woman delectable? It’s time for Molly to teach him a lesson once and for all...but will it lead to “happily ever after”?

Promising start, but I was left with a lot of mixed feelings...

I had a hard time getting into this one.  The prologue was rumored to be one of the best in all of romancedom and RT Book Reviews rated the book a top pick.  Really?  It was entertaining yes.  At least the prologue was.  But the problem with having a strong start to a story is that the reader is set up to expect that strength to be carried through the rest of the book and that does not really happen here.  Now, I admit that things picked back up for me around chapter 8 or 9 but I really had serious mixed feelings throughout this entire book. 

The back cover blurb at the top of this posting really sets things in motion, then the bulk of the book takes place at the house party where the "Most Delectable Companion" contest commences.  The whole scenario is far-fetched - but hey, this is fiction!  And you really have to remember that because there were definite eye-rolling moments for me. 

So, let me give you the lowdown... Harry and Molly have known each other for ages and her sister is married to his brother, making them in-laws by marriage.  Nevertheless, a stunt pulled years ago (prologue) forces both Molly and Harry to "pay" for that incident.  But they meet again several years later when Molly is eloping to Gretna Green with Cedric, a complete fop who doesn't love Molly.  That's ok because she doesn't love him either.  But when they run into Harry and his current mistress, Fiona, at a stop on their way to the silly mistress contest, Harry and Molly exchange a few words.  Next thing you know, Cedric and Fiona run off together!   Yes.  You read that right.  So, now Harry needs a mistress and he strikes a deal with Molly, agreeing to  find her a respectable husband if she wins the contest.  Considering Molly has no experience at being a mistress... you can see where this is going, right?

I don't think I have ever read a book that left me with such mixed feelings.  And judging from other reviews I've read and some conversations I've had with other readers, I am not alone.  This story has some good stuff, but there is so much that is far-fetched or just down-right silly that it almost overwhelms the actual good stuff.  So, let me tell you the things I did like...

The bottom line is, I liked the serious things that happened in this book, not the silly.  I really liked how Molly made friends with the other mistresses and how they were all supporting of each other by mid-week.  It was a competition, yes, but situations and circumstances brought these women closer and there was a warmth that we see grow over the course of the week they spend together.  I also liked many of the quieter moments that Harry and Molly shared.  We see their relationship grow, but the author takes time to draw out their thoughts and feelings and make it seem not so rushed since the bulk of everything happens within a week.  I also liked the other men present at the contest, sans the villain, but wish they could have been more developed in character.  They really come across as half-baked compared to the development of each of the mistresses but since the book series is called the Impossible Bachelors, I know there is more to come with the men in future titles.  I also liked the part at the end when Harry's father showed (in his own way) his love for his son.  See?  I liked all the serious stuff.

Now for the things I didn't like:  I hated the use of the word "we'd" and the author used it a lot in dialogue.  While there are plenty of minor infractions in historical accuracy, this contributed to the appearance that the British English was deliberately dumbed down for the reader.   Julia Quinn takes a more modern approach to her dialogue for fun, and she makes it work but in this book it just made me roll my eyes.   I also rolled my eyes when Harry told Molly they needed to come up with a mistressy name for her so no one would recognize her.  Oh puh-lease.  That's going to throw everyone off the trail.  (Miraculously, of course, it did.)  I'm not a fan of times when a character takes on a dual role because then my brain starts looking for all the times when the author and editor missed using the right name at the right time.  My favorite is on the top of page 194 (line 10) where the snafoo sticks out like a sore thumb, even highlighted with commas!  The last thing I did not like was, fittingly, the ending.  Everything - and I do mean EVERYTHING - came to a wrap all at the same time... at a ball... in front of everyone.  The author literally tied every loose end up in the same ballroom scene and it was just way too many things going on.  I also thought the villain didn't get what he really deserved and after being such a grouch through the entire book, the reasoning behind it all really didn't seem to justify. 

Believe me, I've only just scratched the surface.  Some of the games played during the contest were interesting and well... entertaining.  And watching Harry control his desire for his virginal mistress created a lot of sexual tension.  Hildur, the Icelandic mistress was clueless, which was sometimes funny and sometimes just stupid.  Mixed feelings galore, I tell you!  

So, my last thoughts...  Would I recommend this book?  Only with caution.  The author's website describes Kramer's books as "humorous Regency romance" but be prepared for humor in the form of zany or just plain silly.  If you are like me and prefer more wit rather than silly, pick up Julia Quinn's Bridgerton series or her backlist prior to the Bridgertons.  Will I be reading Kramer's next book?  Yes, but probably not right away.  Curiosity has me wondering what her next book will bring and really it can only go one of two ways: worse or better.  I'm hoping for better but want to clear my brain with a few other books before reading another Kramer title.   Ms. Kramer definitely debuts a great talent for writing.  I just hope the rest of the series books level out a bit.

When Harry Met Molly is book 1 of a 4 book series which I have detailed below.  As a side note, I'm really liking how series books are being released in a much quicker fashion nowadays! 

My rating:  4 – I sort of liked it (but close to 5 - I liked most of the book)

The Impossible Bachelors series...

                                                                                                                        April 2011

Book 4, If You Give a Girl a Viscount, is due out late 2011.  Cover art not available yet.


  1. So sorry to approach you this way but I cant see any contact details.
    I'd love you to review my debt historical romance 'A Dead Man's Debt' which was awarded 'keeper' status by The Romance Reviews and Fiction Books compared to Georgette Heyer!
    Grace x
    Grace Elliot
    'A Dead Man's Debt'

  2. Thanks for your reviews! I definitely agree in terms of getting the language right for historical romance books, it's a big part of the "time machine" feeling I get. I read modern romances too, so why pick up a historical romance if it's going to read the same?